1/4/26 - Performance Reviews Often Feel Awkward in Small Businesses. Here’s How to Make Them Useful
Performance reviews are one of those people-management practices many small businesses quietly avoid. They feel formal, uncomfortable, or unnecessary — especially when teams are small and leaders talk to employees regularly anyway.
But when feedback only happens reactively, employees are often left unsure where they stand or how to grow. A well-handled performance review doesn’t need to feel corporate or rigid — it just needs to be clear, fair, and intentional.
Here are a few focus areas to help make performance conversations more useful and less awkward.
Focus Area 1: When Reviews Are Vague, Feedback Feels Personal
Without clear expectations or examples, feedback can come across as subjective — even when it’s accurate. Statements like “You need to be more proactive” or “You need to improve your attitude” leave employees guessing what success actually looks like.
Useful reviews focus on observable behaviors, specific examples, and clear outcomes. Clarity shifts the conversation from judgment to alignment.
Focus Area 2: Reviews Shouldn’t Be a Surprise
One of the fastest ways to erode trust is delivering feedback during a review that an employee hasn’t heard before. When reviews become a “reveal,” employees focus more on defending themselves than improving.
Effective reviews reinforce conversations that have already happened. They summarize themes, acknowledge progress, and clarify next steps — not introduce new issues out of the blue.
Focus Area 3: Praise Without Direction Doesn’t Drive Growth
Positive feedback matters, but praise alone doesn’t create momentum. Employees also want to know how to keep growing, contributing, or expanding their skills.
A useful review connects strengths to future opportunities. It answers the question employees often won’t ask out loud: “What does growth look like for me here?”
Focus Area 4: Simplicity Beats Formality
Many leaders avoid reviews because they picture long forms, rating scales, and rigid processes. In reality, simple and consistent reviews are far more effective than complex ones that rarely happen.
A short, structured conversation — supported by a few written notes — is often enough to create clarity and accountability without adding burden.
Optional reference:
Harvard Business Review – Why Continuous Feedback Matters More Than Annual Reviews
How This Ties Together
Performance reviews aren’t about grading employees — they’re about aligning expectations, reinforcing trust, and creating shared clarity.
When done well, they reduce tension instead of creating it. They give employees confidence about where they stand and give leaders a clear foundation for future conversations.
Looking Ahead
In the next Bear Brief, we’ll explore how winter slowdowns and post-holiday fatigue affect engagement — and what leaders can do to keep momentum without burning people out.
New briefs are published weekly.
— Bear Essentials HR
New here? Start with What Small Business Leaders Should Know About Managing People to get oriented and make the most of The Bear Brief.